So , DSB+scrubber or just scruber ?

[Jason]

Hi people,

I am just wondering if i should go with an in-sump-DSB and the scrubber or just the scrubber ?
For info the tank is like a JBJ 28G, but will be rim-less, hood-less, internal sump-less, drilled with overflow.

I've read very good things about DSB and the complete opposite as well, and this is a bit misleading......

So, if there is any one here with some long term experience and can share it I'll be more than glad to learn

[FrozenReef]

I wouldn't. In would be counter productive. If DSB is reducing nitrates that your ATS will need. Also, could end up accumulating excess phosphate because there are not enough nitrates for the ATS ( although every tank is different and may not ).

[kerry]

DSB usually have bad results years down the road or if you have to disturb it for what ever unthinkable reason. It can release bad stuff into the water. I have not done the DSB in over a decade. I run scrubber only an could not be happier!!

[SantaMonica]

You will need an ammonia remover somewhere, at least live rock.

[Jason]

You will need an ammonia remover somewhere, at least live rock.

LOL

Of course there will be like 20Kgs (or more) of LR